Qcad Librecad

by Alexandre Prokoudine
LibreCAD / QCAD

LibreCAD is a fully comprehensive 2D CAD application that you can download and install for free. It is a 2D CAD drawing tool based on the community edition of QCad LibreCAD has been re-structured. LibreCAD is an open-source cross-platform 2D CAD program, which is translated in over 30 languages. LibreCAD is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the terms of the GNU General Public License version 2. This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful. With an overall rating of 4 out of 5 stars from its reviewers, LibreCAD surpasses QCAD's average of 2.5 stars from 1 reviews. Both receive lower scores than the category average of 4.3 stars. It should be noted that the category average is 16 features. Librecad wiki librecad originally caduntu is a free and open source 2d cad application which uses qt a cross platform application framework the project started around 2010 as a fork of qcad 2 0 5 0 office center epj willkommen auf office center epj mit allen programmen die das open document format den iso iec standard fur den austausch von office dokumenten unterstuzen konnen die vorlagen von office center epj offnen autocad drawing tree cup 7 dwg ceco net autocad template of treetop in plan. LibreCAD is a free Open Source personal CAD application for Windows, Macintosh and Linux. It is available in more than 20 languages and for all major operating systems, including Microsoft Windows, Mac OS X and Linux (Debian, Ubuntu, Fedora, Mandriva, Suse.

It’s quite disturbing how much controversy a small software niche can get in a relatively small timeframe. As if recent LibreDWG story wasn’t quite sufficient, the most recent news is that Ribbonsoft is not going to release Community Edition of QCAD right now.

The background

QCAD is a CAD system for Windows, Mac and Linux, created by Ribbonsoft and available in two editions: the commercial one and the free one called Community Edition (GPLv2).

The difference between commercial and free versions was mostly about amount of features and the date of availability. According to Andrew, the time gap between them was usually about a year, and it increased while the lead developer was working on QCAD 3, since there was nothing new to release during that period of completely rewriting QCAD.

Indeed, around 2009 the company started rewriting QCAD and released the first public beta version of QCad v3.0 in August 2011. It was the first new public release of QCAD since late 2009. The community edition was years old by the time. The final release of QCAD 3.0 followed in summer 2012.

Before you ask, according to Ribbonsoft, the whole idea of mixing the open source and the closed source business models wasn’t exactly controversial. Andrew says that feedback about QCAD, the QCAD community edition and the business model was mostly positive with very few negative voices.

The lack of strong opinions on the matter could partially be explained by the lack of source code contributions. Reportedly, there have been few patches and more other kinds of contributions — translations, CAD part library items, fonts, hatch patterns. All in all, no reason for hard feelings.

According to Andrew Mustun, an open source version of QCAD 3 was also planned and would have made perfect sense from a community perspective as well as a business perspective:

Some chosen script extensions and modules could have been released under a different license, creating a new business model.

What happened?

LibreCAD arrives

In 2010, Ries van Twisk decided to add CAM features to the Community Edition of QCAD and instead got himself into working on the Qt4 port and then on the core features of what later became LibreCAD.

When I started to do the work and looked around, I noticed there where a lot of complains about that QCad CE was only available for Qt3, and if I would give my CAM program any change to be used by others, I came to the conclusion that I needed a version of QCad in Qt4…

So I decided to make my own port, this would lead me to the advantage of knowing QT’s internals better, in case I needed to know that during my CAM project.

Meanwhile in Ribbonsoft:

While QCAD 2 was being forked into LibreCAD, I was busy working on QCAD 3 which provides a much better architecture for extending and maintaining QCAD and offers a very powerful and complete scripting interface.

Somewhere in the middle of it Ribbonsoft found out that LibreCAD was still using data that didn’t have the same license as the code, and requested the LibreCAD team to remove it.

The LibreCAD team ended up writing new help system and creating new CAD fonts to replace the sorely missing bits of the application.

The rivalry, or lack thereof?

As QCAD 3 was finally released to the masses in mid-2012, people began to wonder if the Community Edition was coming. Some even acquired a license in order to support the QCAD developer and encourage him to release the free version. However, Andrew has a different point of view:

The arrival of LibreCAD makes a new open source release of QCAD 3 in the near future less likely. There is little motivation for me to release anything as open source, knowing that it will immediately be forked.

A fork of QCAD 3 would create redundancy, take away development funding for future versions of QCAD and last but not least challenge my family’s income. Needless to say that all these things are undesirable to me.

This is where the two teams provide mutually contradictory information. According to Andrew:

They (LibreCAD team) never contacted me about this fork or requested any kind of cooperation which would have been my preferred way of doing things. I’d like to point out that the people behind LibreCAD have chosen to be competitors rather than collaborators of QCAD. It is a valid decision, but I cannot emphasize enough that this is their choice, not mine.

Whereas Ries says:

I did contact through the forum, maybe not a direct “I offer to help, here are my generous patches” offer, but reading the response from Andrew, and I am sure you would admit it wasn’t very inviting to work on porting QCad 2.0 to QT4 and supply patches when he was working on Qt3 and not even sure about releasing QCad 3 as GPL.

You are, of course, at liberty to draw your own conclusions, but here it looks more like a rather unfortunate misunderstanding between the two teams. All the better that neither of them is willing to get involved into any further controversies.

In fact, calling the data license incident a controversy would be an exaggeration: both sides came to terms with each other faster than you could say “versus”.

With LibreCAD anf QCAD now going their separate ways there are just few more things to discuss here.

The nearly forgotten CAM module

Since all this fuzz started from a mere wish to get CAM features into QCAD CE, what’s up with CAM in both applications?

Ries van Twisk eventually came back to his original plan and did some work on a CAM module which is available on Github. In December 2012 he stated in a public mailing list:

The current status is that some dialogs are working, but none of the CAM functions are implemented. However, it does give you an idea how plugins in LibreCAD work.

There’s also a prototype of a CAM plug-in by Dietmar Kühn that was last updated about a year ago.

As for QCAD, the situation is not a lot more different there. An automated CAM module for QCAD 3 is currently at alpha stage.

Qcad

QCAD or LibreCAD?

Qcad Ou Librecad

How much do these two applications differ by now? If you take a closer look at QCAD 3.0 and recently released LibreCAD 2.0beta2, you’ll see that the difference is already increasingly large.

Here’s just a raw list of the most important changes from QCAD 2.x to QCAD 3.0:

  • multipage printing;
  • SVG export and import;
  • a new property editor;
  • a new part library browser;
  • working with selection modes;
  • scripting with JavaScript;
  • completely reworked text editing.

As for LibreCAD, a lot of work has gone into making various internal adjustments. The team made some important geometry improvements and added the anticipated advanced snapping. Unfortunately there are some issues as well.

Judging by reports from users, LibreCAD has a problem working with large files, while QCAD handles them rather well. This was going to be addressed by a kernel rewrite, which also involved GPU-based rendering (successfully tested with 1 million lines), but LibreCAD is badly out of active contributors to pursue this goal right now.

In terms of customization it’s hard to say which application is preferable. If you need to change core features, LibreCAD looks like an obvious choice. But if you think that a plug-in would do, QCAD allows writing those in both C++ and ECMAscript, whereas LibreCAD apparently needs more cleanup in the plug-ins department first.

Of course, for a number of people there’s also an ethical choice involved, as in “only free GPL software is OK to run”.

The future

What does it all mean to QCAD and its users? Given the price tag of mere 32 euros, the delayed or completely abandoned release of the Community Edition isn’t likely to seriously affect anyone except probably some government institutions (like public schools) on a really tight budget.

To LibreCAD users who care a lot about GPL it means less choices or more reasons to get involved with development of the application, because the code doesn’t write itself.

Even though growing open hardware and personal fabrication economies are likely to give a big push to engineering, and hence to CAD, right now it doesn’t look like people are rushing to join free CAD software projects. So let’s hope we won’t see too many further forks.

DEVELOPER :LibreCAD
PLATFORM :Windows / Linux / Mac
LICENSE :GNU General Public License

Qcad Library

LibreCAD is a free Open Source personal CAD application for Windows, Macintosh and Linux. It is available in more than 20 languages and for all major operating systems, including Microsoft Windows, Mac OS X and Linux (Debian, Ubuntu, Fedora, Mandriva, Suse, . . . ).

LibreCAD is a feature-packed and mature 2D-CAD application with some really great advantages:

  • It's free no worry about license costs or annual fees.
  • No language barriers it's available in a large number of languages, with more being added continually.
  • GPLv2 public license you can use it, customize it, hack it and copy it with free user support and developer support from our active worldwide community and ou experienced developer team.
  • LibreCAD is an Open Source community-driven project: development is open to new talent and new ideas, and our software is tested and used daily by a large and devoted user community; you, too, can get involved and influence its future development.

* LibreCAD download link provides gnu general public license version of the software for Windows and MacOS.

QCADVersion:3.25 · RibbonSoft

QCAD is an application for computer aided drafting in two dimensions (2d).

FreeMatVersion:4.2 · Samit Basu

FreeMat is a free open source numerical computing environment and programming language, similar to MATLAB and GNU Octave.

Euler Math ToolboxVersion:2021 · Rene Grothmann
Qcad Librecad

Euler is a free and open-source numerical software package.

Thonny comes with Python 3.7 built in, so just one simple installer is needed and you're ready to learn programming. (You can also use a separate Python installation, if necessary.) The initial user interface is stripped of all features that may distract beginners. MicroPython is an implementation of the Python programming language that is already popular among Raspberry Pi users. MicroPython is built specifically for microcontrollers like the RP2040 that powers Raspberry Pi Pico. MicroPython offers the same friendly syntax as Python. Thonny micropython library. Create MicroPython File in Thonny IDE. First, we need to create a main.py file that will contain our main program code which would be executed. To create a new file click on the new file icon (1). After that copy the following code in a new file and save it by clicking the save icon (2) with the name main.py. Thonny 2.2 has plug-ins which add more general support for various MicroPython devices – see for more info.

Compare
ScilabVersion:6.1.0 · Scilab Enterprises

Scilab is free and open source software for numerical computation providing a powerful computing environment for engineering and scientific applications.

Critical Depth Calculator in Open Channel FlowsVersion:0.1 · Hamed Mohammadi

Qcad Vs Librecad 2018

This is an application for calculating critical depth in open channels flow.

CMS IntelliCADVersion:10.0 · CAD-Manufacturing Solutions, Inc.

CMS IntelliCAD Compatible CAD Software is the intelligent and affordable full-featured choice for engineers, architects and consultants, or anyone who communicates using CAD drawings.

No comments yet. Be the first to comment.

Qcad Vs Librecad

Submit a review using your Facebook ID